Defect #331

chatroom names in upercase are not allowed

Added by Vicente J. Ruiz Jurado over 12 years ago. Updated almost 12 years ago.

Status:ClosedStart date:08/14/2012
Priority:NormalDue date:
Assignee:Samer -% Done:

100%

Category:Chat
Target version:-
Resolution: Tags:

Description

Maybe others like list has the same problem...

Associated revisions

Revision ba662b4f
Added by Samer - about 12 years ago

Specifying "lowercase" in the error message for chatroom names, ref
#331

History

#1 Updated by Vicente J. Ruiz Jurado about 12 years ago

  • Assignee changed from Vicente J. Ruiz Jurado to Samer -

Some check should be done in the form.

#2 Updated by Samer - about 12 years ago

Right now:
(1) chatroom names must be just lowercase (e.g. roomname)
(2) list names can be a mix of lowercase and uppercase (e.g. ListName, LISTNAME)

I am not sure how to understand this issue. I guess it means to generalise the behaviour of (2), but I'm not sure. Could you confirm?

#3 Updated by Vicente J. Ruiz Jurado about 12 years ago

I don't know if xmpp chat rooms allow uppercase names... I prefer to limit to lowercase in the form panel all that names...

#4 Updated by Samer - about 12 years ago

I checked and although it's unclear to me in the XEP-0045, there are multiple issues with jabber room-names using uppercase, so I support keeping it lowercase.

Then, I don't understand why this issue is not closed :) Kune already does not allow you to create uppercase names for chat-rooms (*), and a chat-room name cannot be changed later on.

If it's not closed because the same limitation should be imposed in lists... well, I'm not convinced about that. Why using in Kune-lists the same limitations of mailing-lists? Unless some kind of retro compatibility is planned (pretty difficult) I don't see the point.

(*): I will clarify the message, specifying "lowercase" characters

#5 Updated by Samer - almost 12 years ago

  • Status changed from New to Closed
  • % Done changed from 0 to 100

I close this issue, as lists were corrected in a commit at some point. Now they won't allow anything but lowerspace letters.

Also available in: Atom PDF